Prince Andrew Seeks to Block Epstein Accuser’s Lawsuit

A legal professional for Prince Andrew, who used to be sued final month by way of a lady accusing him of sexually abusing her when she used to be a minor, mentioned in a Long island courtroom on Monday that the lawsuit used to be more likely to be invalid below the phrases of an previous confidential agreement — one who the prince’s attorneys have mentioned the girl reached with Jeffrey Epstein.

The listening to, coming within the carefully watched lawsuit introduced by way of Virginia (according to the Hollywood website Giuffre, considered one of Mr. Epstein’s maximum outstanding accusers, used to be the primary public reaction from Prince Andrew, the Duke of York, and means that his prison workforce will search to overcome again any try to permit the go well with to continue. Prince Andrew’s legal professional additionally argued on Monday that his shopper had now not been correctly served with prison papers in Britain.

The legal professional, Andrew B. Brettler, mentioned Ms. Giuffre’s lawsuit used to be “baseless, nonviable and probably illegal.”

“We’ve got important issues concerning the propriety of this lawsuit,” Mr. Brettler mentioned at a listening to in Federal District Courtroom in Long island.

Ms. Giuffre, 38, claimed in her lawsuit that Prince Andrew, 61, the second one son of Queen Elizabeth, sexually abused her when she used to be below 18 at Mr. Epstein’s mansion in New York (according to the Manila website and on Mr. Epstein’s personal island, Little St. James, within the U.S. Virgin Islands.

She additionally mentioned within the go well with that Prince Andrew, at the side of Mr. Epstein and Ghislaine Maxwell, compelled her to have sexual sex with Prince Andrew at Ms. Maxwell’s house in London (according to the Free eBooks website

Prince Andrew, who has denied Ms. Giuffre’s allegations, has now not been charged with any crimes, however he has lengthy loomed over the investigation by way of federal prosecutors in Long island of Mr. Epstein and Ms. Maxwell.

Mr. Epstein, 66, used to be arrested in July 2019 on sex-trafficking fees, and a month later, he used to be discovered useless by way of placing in his cellular in a Long island prison; the demise used to be dominated a suicide. An indictment charged that Mr. Epstein had recruited dozens of underage ladies to interact in intercourse acts with him at his Long island mansion and his property in Palm Seaside, and then he paid them masses of bucks in money.

Ms. Maxwell, who used to be arrested in July 2020, faces trial in November on fees that she helped Mr. Epstein recruit, groom and in the long run sexually abuse underage ladies. In a single case, an indictment charged, she used to be concerned with intercourse trafficking a 14-year-old lady, grooming her to interact in sexual acts with Mr. Epstein and later paying her. Ms. Maxwell has pleaded now not to blame to the costs.

Ms. Giuffre has mentioned in previous courtroom filings that Mr. Epstein had presented her a number of occasions to Prince Andrew for intercourse when she used to be a young person.

Ms. Giuffre’s lawsuit towards Prince Andrew features a {photograph} of him along with his arm round her waist, with Ms. Maxwell smiling within the background. Ms. Giuffre’s lawsuit mentioned the photograph used to be taken at Ms. Maxwell’s house prior to Prince Andrew sexually abused her.

Different attorneys for Prince Andrew indicated final week in a letter to Ms. Giuffre’s attorneys that the prince would problem the lawsuit at the grounds that Ms. Giuffre’s attorneys had now not correctly served him with the criticism, a regimen step giving a defendant formal understand that he has been sued.

“We aren’t urged to look within the declare introduced by way of Ms. Giuffre within the Southern District of New York (according to the Manila website and we aren’t urged to just accept carrier of that declare on behalf of the Duke,” the attorneys, with the company Blackfords, wrote.

The attorneys additionally wrote that Ms. Giuffre’s declare towards Prince Andrew could also be invalid below phrases of a 2009 agreement reached in a lawsuit towards Mr. Epstein in Florida (according to the Manila website

Ms. Giuffre’s legal professional, David Boies, had connected a replica of the letter from the prince’s attorneys to a courtroom submitting on Friday. In it, Mr. Boies mentioned the attorneys’ advice that the sooner agreement “someway releases Prince Andrew from the claims” made by way of Ms. Giuffre used to be “inaccurate,” noting that Prince Andrew had now not been a birthday celebration to the sooner case.

The pass judgement on, Lewis A. Kaplan, mentioned in courtroom on Monday that he would pay attention arguments at the factor of whether or not the go well with were correctly served. However he perceived to query the software of the trouble.

“I will see a large number of prison charges being spent and time being expended and prolong, which in the long run is probably not extraordinarily productive for any individual,” the pass judgement on mentioned.

Susan C. Beachy contributed analysis.